Deep dives · Returns
Returns: how many are ordered, how many carried out
Every year Italy orders tens of thousands of citizens of countries outside the European Union to leave its territory. Only some of them are actually returned, and how many depends above all on their country of citizenship.
Orders to leave Italy and returns
Orders to leave Italy and returns,
People each year. The shading is the gap between orders and returns.
Orders and returns, by citizenship
The light bar shows orders to leave Italy, the solid bar the returns carried out, on the same scale. The period and sort order apply to this chart only.
Table: orders and returns by citizenship, year by year
Country by country, year by year
From Italy to the country of citizenship
How to read these numbers
The ratio of returns to orders is an approximation: someone returned in one year may have received the order earlier, and the same person can receive more than one. The figures, from Eurostat on Ministry of the Interior data, do not include people turned back at the border and may not match the Ministry’s own published figures.
How the numbers were built, and sources
What these numbers count
Orders are citizens of non-EU countries whom Italy has ordered to leave its territory; returns are those who left after an order, through a forced or voluntary return. People who leave Italy without anyone recording it are not counted. Eurostat rounds every value to 5, and the totals also include stateless people and people of unknown citizenship, who do not appear in the list of countries: this is why the sum of the countries can differ from the total (by 1,140 orders in 2008, almost all of unknown citizenship).
Orders and returns are not the same people
This is why a country can have more returns than orders in a given year. The ratio is affected by, among other things, readmission agreements with individual countries and the availability of flights and of places in detention centres.
Why the ratio is shown only where there are enough orders
With few orders, a handful of people can move the ratio by many points. The ranking by returns per 100 orders therefore only includes countries with at least 250 orders a year on average over the chosen period (1,000 over four years); in the other sort orders, the ratio for countries below that threshold is shown in grey.
From where, to where
Eurostat records the citizenship of the people returned, not the country where they land; the two almost always coincide, but for Italy the actual destination is not published. On the map every line starts from Italy as a whole: the data do not say from which city, airport or pre-removal detention centre each person left.
Sources
The data can be rebuilt with python3 scripts/build_rimpatri.py. For the method behind the whole atlas: Methodology and sources.
More deep dives
Foreign nationals in Italian prisons
How many there are, from which countries, for which crimes, and why the comparison with residents should be read with caution.
Read the deep dive Perception and realityHow unsafe we feel, and how unsafe we are
Fear of crime alongside reported crimes: in Italy as a whole, in the big cities and province by province.
Read the deep dive Unknown offendersHow many crimes remain without a known offender
How many reported crimes have a known offender: crime by crime, in the big cities and province by province.
Read the deep dive MinorsMinors reported and arrested
How many there are among the people reported, for which crimes and region by region: the numbers since 2004, their share since 2014.
Read the deep dive Pre-trial detentionIn prison before the verdict
How many people are held without a final conviction, and how much the State pays when custody turns out to be unjust, district by district.
Read the deep dive Prison by prisonHow full prisons are, and how many people die in them
Prison by prison, the people held and the places available month by month since 2019, and deaths in prison according to who counts them.
Read the deep dive TrialsFrom crime to verdict
How many cases prosecutors open, how long trials and appeals last, how many end because time runs out: district by district and court by court.
Read the deep dive Outside prisonSentences served outside prison
Probation, home detention, semi-liberty and probation before trial: how many people, how it has changed since 2014, region by region.
Read the deep dive